Phil. 4, section 2
Spring 2018Catalog: PHIL 4. Critical Thinking. Study of the basic skills of good reasoning needed for the intelligent and responsible conduct of life. Topics include: argument structure and identification, validity and strength of arguments, common fallacies of reasoning, use and abuse of language in reasoning, principles of fair play in argumentation. Units: 3.0.
Text: There is no required text for this course. All readings for the course are online or in SacCT. The readings for each week are listed and linked on the scheduleunder the relevant weeks.Course Description: This course is designed to improve one of the fundamental intellectual abilities, the capacity to think critically. A well-trained critical thinker has a number of skills that we will develop and practice.
Link to Course ScheduleThe knowledge and skills to be studied in this course include:
Logical analysis and the identification and construction of arguments.Student Outcome Goals: At the end of the course the student should have the ability to:
Understanding logical relations, in particular the relations between premises and conclusions.
Recognizing the more common forms of formal and informal fallacies.
Evaluating the relevance, validity, and strength of arguments.
Understanding the logical structure of deductive and inductive arguments.
Awareness of the abuses of language, including connotation, ambiguity, and definition.
Recognizing arguments in a variety of contexts, including other disciplines as well as in public affairs.
Improve ‘information competence’: the ability to find out what one needs to know in order to have a responsible position on an issue.
Acquiring an immunity to propaganda.
Developing not only the capacity but the disposition to use good reasoning in a variety of contexts.
Developing a sense of fairness and respect for opposing positions.
Developing basic thinking skills that are applicable to a variety of academic subjects and students' lives as citizens, consumers, leaders, and moral agents.
Improving our ability to argue fairly, and to handle bias, emotion, and propaganda.
Locate the argument in a passageScientific Reasoning, Critical Thinking, and the Paranormal: We will be considering arguments from a variety of sources such as the television news media, newspapers, politicians, statistical studies, science, parapsychologists, pseudo-science and so on. American pop culture provides lots of interesting critical thinking case studies. Among other things, we will be looking at a number of claims and arguments offered by parapsychologists, paranormalists, and pseudo-science as test cases for critical thinking analysis. Critical thinking skills can be applied to great advantage to topics like ESP, clairvoyance, astrology, chiropractic, homeopathy, ghosts, unusual creatures like Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster, alien visitations, and so on. We will see how scientific reasoning that addresses double blind controls, the placebo effect, confirmation bias, and other issues is the best method for finding truth and avoiding error.
Detect errors of reasoning and explain how the reasoning is in error.
Engage in cogent and respectful discussion.
Analyze specific arguments for consistency and credibility.
Apply good reasoning to issues in professional and personal contexts.
Evaluate evidence and make appropriate inferences from that evidence.
Determine what evidence is necessary and know how to find that evidence, if possible.
Construct and defend arguments in support of or in opposition to particular propositions.
Analyze and solve complicated strategic challenges.
Student Assessment: Students' abilities to meet these outcome goals will be evaluated with SacCT assessments, homework assignments, in class midterm and final exams, and class attendance and participation.
Grading: There will be 16 SacCT quizzes given throughout the semester. The lowest score will be dropped. There will be an Argument Strength homework assignment (10%) and an Argument Reconstruction Homework assignment (10%). There will be a midterm and a final exam.
|SacCT Quizzes||15 (4% each) out of 16||60%|
Some Advice about the SacCT assessments: The quizzes on SacCT are designed to assess student's mastery of concepts, techniques, and content that is presented in lectures and in the book. They are also designed to teach--later quizzes depend upon former quizzes, they are progressively harder, and they focus on different aspects of the various critical thinking skills we are trying to learn. The quizzes are timed, usually 30 minutes, and they are not repeatable. They are also only available to be taken for a limited time. So plan accordingly and be thoroughly prepared when you begin the quiz. Here is some advice about preparing for the quizzes and doing well on them: Preparing for Blackboard Quizzes
How to take quizzes in SacCT: Go to http://www.csus.edu/lms/. Login using your CSUS Saclink ID and your password. Click on the link in your menu for this course. Then go to "Assessments" on the left. That page will list all of the live quizzes. Got to SacCT Resources for more information on how SacCT works.
Go to: https://www.google.com/accounts/ManageAccount If you don't already have an account, create one with the link on the lower right. Please don't use a pseudonym that is not recognizable as your name--I won't be able to give credits for posts from a mystery student named "oNixJUmper3." If you already have an account with a pseudonym, email me with your name and the account name. Also put your name on the Google Doc you are creating for the course.
Video: Instructions for Creating a Google Doc for Prof. McCormick's classes.
1. After you have established a Google account, you can go to this page https://www.google.com/accounts/ManageAccount to access other services, or you can go to www.google.com and login.
2. In the upper right hand corner, there are links in a pattern of 9 dots. Click on that, and then click on Drive.
3. To create a new document, click "Create" in the upper left hand corner, and click on "Document."
4. Type your work and edit it in the window that opens.
5. Give it a title by clicking on "Untitled Document" in the upper left, and renaming it. Your work will be periodically saved automatically.
You will create one document for this course. It should be named last name Critical Thinking. e.g. Smith Critical Thinking
I collect and put student work into folders by the title. Please do not put anything else in the title than last name Critical Thinking. No hyphens, quotes, dashes, commas, and so on. And please do not title the whole document after the heading for the first entry or I won't be able to find the work and give you credit for it.
All of your written work for the course will go into this file--Do not create multiple, separate files for the different assignments. One student, one document.
Do not share your Google Doc with anyone else except me and my teaching assistants.
I will track when the projects and papers were completed with the Revision History function in Google Docs. Any changes made to the documents made after the due date and time will be recorded there and be treated as late work according to the late policies on the Office Hours and Course Policies page.
As each project is due, open the document and add the project for that week to the top so that the document will contain all of them at the end of the semester. Each project will have a section heading in bold listed in the assignments.
6. Save the document with the "Save" button in the upper right.
7. Also on the upper right is a "Share" button. Click on it, then click on "Invite People." Be sure the "can edit" option is checked. If you don't share it with me as a collaborator, I cannot grade your work.
8. In the box that comes up, enter my email address: firstname.lastname@example.org
9. Click: Invite Collaborators
10. Be sure to put your name on the document and in the message to me with your assignments.
11. Send it (bottom right), and be sure to send a copy to yourself for backup.
12. Explore the other functions in the Google docs program.
13. If you prefer to write your work in another program, do so, and then cut and paste it into Google Docs.
If you do upload a document, be sure to re-title your essay according to step 6 and follow the rest of the steps. Also be sure that the formatting has been preserved.
Here are a couple of videos explaining how Google Docs works:
Google Docs in Plain English
Sharing Options in Google Docs
Critical Thinking Journal Entries
For most weeks in the semester, there will be an outside project to complete in addition to our classroom work. These projects involve doing online readings or studying a video lecture and then completing some sort of writing assignment about them. Then you will be required to answer several questions about the material. You will put these assignments in your Google Doc. The Video Projects are linked on the calender and they are listed hereGrading Criteria for Journal Entries: There are too many students and too many entries for me to give many individual comments or grades on them. I will give everyone some feedback early on in the semester, then it is up to the student to follow these criteria to receive full credit:1) All of the entries must be completed. Any missing projects will result in a proportional reduction in the overall grade.2) All of the journal entries must be completed on time. The time and date when it was submitted is available to me in the Revision History tab of Google Docs. Any revisions that occur after the due date will also be evident in the Revision History view. Late assignments will not be accepted.3) All of the questions in the individual projects must be addressed. And they must be addressed specifically and thoroughly. A good strategy is to quote the entire assignment in your entry and address each part separately.4) It will vary from project to project, but doing a thorough and acceptable job of addressing the questions will typically take at least 300 words. A few sentences or two short paragraphs won't be sufficient.5) The entries must be completely free of spelling, grammar, and structure errors. They must meet the standards of written college English. Any entries that have spelling, grammar, and writing structure errors will not receive credit.6) The entries must reflect a clear understanding of the arguments, concepts, principles, and distinctions that the philosopher in the video makes. The entries must be long enough and detailed enough to reflect your understanding.7) If you are in doubt, write more. Take the opportunity to expand on the topic and questions under consideration. Offer some of your own ideas in addition to addressing the project questions. Entries that are only 5 sentences long, for example, will not receive credit.During the semester, and at the end, I will review all of your entries and determine to what extent they have satisfied these criteria. The grade on this portion of the coursework will be proportional.
Students with Disabilities
If you have a disability and require accommodations, you need to provide disability documentation to SSWD, Lassen Hall 1008, 916-278-6955.Please discussion your accommodation needs with me after class or during my office hours early in the semester.
Catalog description PHIL 4. Critical Thinking. 3 Units General Education Area/Graduation Study of the basic skills of good reasoning needed for the intelligent and responsible conduct of life. Topics include: argument structure and identification, validity and strength of arguments, common fallacies of reasoning, use and abuse of language in reasoning, principles of fair play in argumentation.
This course satisfies area A3 of your G.E. (General Education) requirements.
When does our class meet?
This course is 100% online, including the tests. To get started, keep reading.
The required textbook Logical Reasoning is free online at my personal webpage.
For extra reading, I recommend your working on the aids at http://highered.mcgraw-hill.com/sites/0073386677/student_view0/index.html. Here you will find a summary of our main topics, frequently asked questions with answers, and sample tests with answers.
Our course is designed to improve your skills at making wise decisions about what to believe and do. Your critical thinking skills are your skills at making judgments. Not snap judgments that occur in the blink of an eye, but those that require careful reasoning. You use your critical thinking skills to
- grasp the point that a writer or speaker is trying to make,
- detect whether someone's claim needs more evidence to back it up,
- distinguish between strong arguments and weak ones,
- generate reasons for your viewpoint on some issue,
- decide what information in a piece of writing or speaking to accept and use, and decide what information to reject and not use,
- reason from a hypothetical assumption,
- make a potentially strong argument stronger,
- practice conscious quality control as you think,
- foreseeing problems.
Critical thinking skills involve the ability to reason, to assemble evidence in order to develop a position, and to communicate complex ideas. These skills are of practical value to anyone, and they will be taught here independent of subject matter. Our course will not emphasize philosophy over any other subject.
The central core of your critical thinking skills is your ability to detect, generate and evaluate reasons given in support of some conclusionoften also called the "key proposition" or "point" or "thesis." This conclusion might be a new belief, or a change in plans, or a confirmation that the old beliefs are OK. The technical term for a set of reasons plus their intended conclusion is an "argument." So, the central topic of this course is argumentation. Not argumentation in the sense of quarrels, but argumentation in the sense of giving reasons to support some conclusion or other.
Although many scientific studies of decision making have shown that people tend to sift sources of information to reinforce existing views rather than to accept the view that is backed up with the better argument, our course is designed to combat this tendency.
Our course is concerned with many other kinds of reasoning, not just with argumentation. For example, when you are trying to summarize a complicated explanation of allowable deductions on I.R.S. income tax form 1040 Schedule C, you are not arguing, but you are doing some critical thinking. Your critical thinking skills also involve assessing whether a group of sentences are consistent, whether a proposed definition is successful, whether an advertisement gives any useful information about a product, whether a speaker is being fair in a debate with an opponent, whether a statistical sample was biased, and whether someone's supposed scientific explanation is unscientific. Our course will try to improve all these other critical thinking skills, too, even though they don't directly involve arguments.
In a republican nation, whose citizens are to be led by reason and persuasion and not by force, the art of reasoning becomes of the first importance.
One of your most valuable critical thinking skills is illustrated in the following transcript of a radio conversation between a large U.S. naval ship and Canadian authorities off the coast of Newfoundland.
Americans: Please divert your course 15 degrees to the North to avoid a collision with us.
Canadians: Recommend you divert YOUR course 15 degrees to the south to avoid a collision.
Americans: This is the Captain of a U.S. Navy ship. I say again, divert YOUR course.
Canadians: No, I say again, you divert YOUR course.
Americans: THIS IS THE AIRCRAFT CARRIER USS MISSOURI. WE ARE A LARGE WARSHIP OF THE U.S. NAVY. DIVERT YOUR COURSE NOW!
Canadians: This is a light house. Your call.
Hopefully, the Captain changed course. Critical thinkers will alter their beliefs and actions in light of new evidence. Inflexible thinkers won't.
For more details about what our course is about, visit the overview page.
This is a skills course, not a look-up-the-answer course nor a know-these-facts course. The primary goal of this course is to develop your critical thinking skills, not to teach you a body of knowledge. More specifically, the course aims to improve your ability to do the following things:
1. Locate the argument in a passage.
2. Detect errors of reasoning and explain how the reasoning is in error.
3. Evaluate evidence and make appropriate inferences from that evidence.
4. Write an argumentative essay.
5. Rewrite an argumentative essay to improve it.
6. Write clearly as you apply the other skills on this list.
7. Distinguish whether an argument's conclusion follows with certainty or only with probability from its premises [i.e., distinguish deductive validity from inductive strength].
8. Identify the issue in a disagreement.
9. Detect logical inconsistency.
10. Detect and remove vagueness and ambiguity, but do not confuse being explicit with being objective.
11. Identify the point or purpose of someone's remark. For example, is the person asking something, making a claim, arguing, threatening, or joking?
12. Create an argument that avoids the fallacies and makes a plausible case for a position on an issue.
13. Given an argument on a controversial issue, create a plausible argument that defends a different (or the opposite) conclusion.
14. Detect when someone is asking a bad question because it's loaded, or because it's a red herring.
15. Explain in what way this is analogous to that.
16. Compare the quality of two competing explanations.
17. Identify implicit assumptions.
18. Be less gullible than you were before taking the course.
One goal for our course is to improve your writing ability.
Here is a more formal presentation of the GE learning goals for this course (and available at http://www.csus.edu/acaf/portfolios/ge/geareaa3.stm):
- Students study about and consciously develop skills in critical thinking.
- Knowledge through logical analysis and argument construction is pursued throughout the course.
- Instruction develops understanding of logical relationships between premises and conclusions.
- Instruction develops ability to recognize more common formal and informal fallacies.
- Grading reflects emphasis on logical processes.
- Develops basic skills, applicable to a variety of academic subjects and to the fulfillment of such roles as citizen, consumer, leader and moral agent.
- Skill in evaluating the validity, strength and relevance of arguments.
- A sense of logical structure of both inductive and deductive forms.
- Awareness of uses and abuses of argument language, including connotation, ambiguity and definition.
- Skill in handling a variety of arguments in variety of contexts.
- Ability to argue fairly and to handle bias, emotion, and propaganda.
As you read, it is helpful first to skim the assignment to get some sense of what's ahead. Look at how it is organized and what cues, if any, the author provides to signify main ideas (section titles, bold face, boxes). Make your own notes as you read. Stop every ten or fifteen minutes to look back over what you've read and try to summarize the key ideas for yourself by asking yourself, "What was the point of all that?" This periodic pausing and reviewing will help you maintain your concentration, process the information more deeply, and retain it longer. You'll be given sample questions now and then to help guide your studying for future assignments, but answering an actual homework or test question usually will require you to apply your knowledge to new questions not specifically discussed in class nor in the required reading. This ability to use your knowledge in new situations requires study activities different from memorizing. You goal is to improve your skills, not simply to memorize.
At the end of the course, students will be able to:
1. Describe, explain and distinguish key concepts in critical thinking.
2. Identify an argument in a passage of ordinary text, including identifying the premises and conclusions and distinguishing them from extraneous information.
3. Identify errors of reasoning and explain what the error is.
4. Engage with peers in cogent and respectful discussion.
5. Analyze specific arguments for consistency and credibility.
6. Apply good reasoning to issues and problems in professional and personal contexts.
7. Evaluate evidence and draw inferences from that evidence.
This course has no prerequisites. It is designed to be taken in the second semester of your first year of college, but you can take it any semester you wish.
Add policy: To add the course, try to do so by using CMS, else write the instructor.
Drop policy: This course has participation and activity requirements, including engagement with the course material on a weekly basis. Students who do NOT participate during the first two weeks by either completing the first week’s email assignment or taking the second week’s quiz will be considered to have abandoned the course and may be administratively dropped by the instructor. Re-enrolment will not be permitted.
To drop the course on purpose during the first two weeks, use the CMS system. No paperwork is required. After the first two weeks, it is harder to drop, and a departmental form from the Dept. Secretary in MND 3000 is required; the form is called "Petition to Add/Drop After Deadline." It requires stating a good reason for dropping. As with any university course, make sure you are dropped officially (by CMS or the instructor or the department secretary); don't simply walk away into the ozone, or else you will get a "U" grade for the course, which is counted as an "F" by the Registrar in computing your GPA (grade point average).
Your grade will be determined by weekly assignments, a midterm and a final examination. The weekly assignments might be homework questions, an essay, a crossword puzzle, or a quiz.
Notice in the Schedule of Assignments and Due Dates how much each week's assignment counts as part of the total grade. In SacCT you will find a more detailed description of each week's assignment. Weekly assignments are due each Friday.
You are expected to do your own final work on all assignments, although it is OK to discuss assignments with others before you actually write up or choose your answers. Emailing another student for their answers so you can use them is not what is meant by allowable discussion.
After each homework or quiz is graded, I'll post within SacCT your grade, the grading scale, and a representative sample of the answers with explanations of them. The grading scale and answers will be viewable by everyone, but your own grade will be viewable only by you and me; no other student will be able to see your grade.
It's possible for everyone to get an A grade; I don't curve the results to force a certain number of D's and F's, although I sometimes curve the other way to ensure a sufficient number of A's each week.
This is a paper-less course. You don't give me any paper. You do all the work for this course online, and you do not need to meet me or the other students in a classroom. For each week's assignment, you send in all your work by computer, and you can do your work any day of that week and any time of day you wish. You are never required to be online at any particular time of the day nor any particular day of the week. But you have to do something each week. Also, even if you can view a future week's assignment, you are not allowed to complete it in advance, because the assignment might change a few hours before the week begins.
It is recommended that you finish an assignment before the last day it is due. That way, if you are sick the day the assignment is due or have computer problems that day or just have a bad hair day, then you won't have to worry about the Phil. 4 assignment.
You are penalized for not doing an assignment on time even if you are sick, because you had an entire week to do that assignment. There are . Without this policy, I'd be having to create make-up assignments for every week for somebody.
. Late homework is accepted for three days after the due date; but the later it is, the more your grade suffers, which is one-third letter grade per day, including weekend days. The quizzes must be taken by the due date.
Below is a schedule of topics to be covered in the course.
Week 1: What is critical thinking?
Week 2: Claims, issues, and arguments
Week 3: Argument structure
Week 4: Ways to be imprecise
Week 5: Evaluating claims
Week 6: Arguing fairly
Week 7: Fallacies
Week 8: Review
Week 9: Midterm
Week 10: Consistency and contradiction
Week 11: Deductive logic
Week 12: Explanations
Week 13: Inductive Arguments
Week 14: Scientific reasoning
Week 15: Review for the final exam
You will take this course wholly on a computer (any computer is OK) over the Internet (the web).
If you don't already have a SacLink account, go ahead and get one. CSUS students can create a free SacLink account for web access (and e-mail, too) by visiting https://mysaclink.csus.edu/Default.aspx, or by making a short visit in person to any student computer lab.
No matter how, or from where, you access the Internet, in order to gain entry to the SacCT web pages of our course you will need to use your SacLink User name as your SacCT username and use your SacLink password as your SacCT password.
During the semester, you will need elementary word processing skills such as the ability to type a sentence, to create and save a text document using your favorite word processor, and to copy a paragraph from that document and paste it into another document (such as into an e-mail to me). These skills aren't hard to learn, and the best way to get them is either to ask a friend for advice or to visit a campus computer lab and talk to the student assistant there. Don't bother reading manuals.
Campus computer labs
The labs are here.
You can get help about SacLink and about getting your computer to work with our course by going to one of these labs and speaking with the student who is running it or telephoning their help desk at 278-7337.
- You will work all the test questions and homework questions on your own and won't receive the answers from other students, nor give them to other students.
- At the moment, SacCT contains a rough draft of every assignment for every week of the course, so you can look ahead to get a good idea of what is coming. However, I often change assignments on the Saturday morning before a week begins, so I expect you not to work future assignments until the week begins in which they are actually due.
- You will seek help or advice about the course if you need it rather than waiting until the end of the semester.
- You will be courteous to other students. If you are assigned to do a group project with someone you don't particularly like, you will do it anyway; you are in training to be a professional.
- You will be honest and won't cheat by plagiarizing (copying) from someone else. For more information see the University's policy on honesty and cheating. A student tutorial on how not to plagiarize is available online from our library.
If you have a disability and require accommodations, you need to provide disability documentation to SSWD, Lassen Hall 1008 (phone 916-278-6955). Then see me early in the semester so that appropriate arrangements can be made to ensure your full participation in class. See also http://www.csus.edu/sswd/index.html.
You are expected to be honest in your academic work. For more details, visit this link to the University's policy on academic honesty at http://www.csus.edu/umanual/student/STU-0100.htm
My office is in Mendocino Hall 3022, phone 916-278-7384. My weekly office hours there are Monday and Wednesday 10:45 - 11:55. Feel free to stop by or to telephone at any of those times. If those times are inconvenient for you, then we can arrange an appointment for an alternative time. In addition I hold online office hours within SacCT every Wednesday night 9-10 P.M.
You may send e-mail to me any time at email@example.com. Once you have access to the SacCT program (see below), you should send nearly all your course related email to me at 'Bradley Dowden (Instructor)' within the SacCT mail program. Regardless of how you send me email, you should expect a response within 24 hours, usually much sooner. My personal web page at http://www.csus.edu/indiv/d/dowdenb/index.htm has the telephone number of the Philosophy Department's secretary, a mailing address, and other info about me.
The first thing to do is to go get a SacLink password, then enter SacCT below and read all the web pages in the table of contents for the first week of our course, and follow their directions. Below is more info on how to do this.
When you've been officially registered in the course by the University, a day later they will tell the SacCT computer program to allow you into the rest of the course (provided the semester has started), but I probably won't allow students into SacCT until a few days before the semester begins.
Your SacCT UserName is the same as your SacLink account name. It looks something like sac87888, but with different numbers just for you. When you apply for a SacLink account, the Administration's computer looks deep into your soul and assigns you a number based on the order in which you applied.
When you get a SacLink account, you will also get a SacLink password which you will use each time you use the University computers. It is also your password into the SacCT program. You will never need to tell me this password (and be suspicious of any email that asks you for it).
I'm glad you're interested in taking the course. I'll try to help you if you get stuck somewhere. If you ever have trouble with SacLink or with logging in to the University from home, call the SacLink help desk at 916-278-7337, and the student who answers will try to help you. If you have trouble and are in a campus computer lab, just ask the student who is working in the lab. If all that fails, contact me.
Your goal now is to enter SacCT. You do not need to do anything in order to be registered for access to SacCT; once you are offically enrolled in the course with the University, then your enrollment in SacCT happens automatically near the beginning of the semester. Then when you click to enter SacCT you will be allowed to enter.
And for a first exercise in critical thinking while you are waiting for the course to begin, you should know that on eBay you can purchase a $500 scholarship to our university for only $1,000. This is a great deal, and no person is turned down. Please send your $1,000 to the address in Nigeria that is indicated in the eBay announcement that will arrive soon.
If you are already registered in the course and have your Saclink password (and it's less than a week before the semester begins), then you are ready to enter SacCT.